Texas Sen. Ted Cruz (R) and California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) engaged in a public exchange on Feb. 16, with Cruz labeling Newsom 'historically illiterate' over remarks regarding Newsom’s executive actions. Newsom responded with a pointed rebuttal, prompting Cruz to post a clown emoji on social media.
The clash follows weeks of tension between the two officials, who have traded critiques over policy priorities, including Newsom’s recent executive orders on energy and education. Cruz’s comment came during a Senate floor speech addressing federal-state relations, while Newsom addressed the matter in a late-night press briefing.
What the Left Is Saying
Newsom’s administration defended his approach as grounded in 'modern governance and progressive values,' per a statement from his press secretary, Ana Matosantos. 'Governor Newsom’s leadership is rooted in addressing today’s challenges, not clinging to outdated historical narratives,' Matosantos said.
Progressive commentators amplified the criticism of Cruz’s remark. California Assemblymember Evan Williams (D) called the senator’s comment 'dismissive of California’s role in shaping national history' and noted Newsom’s approval rating among state Democrats remains above 60%.
What the Right Is Saying
Cruz’s office characterized Newsom’s response as 'deflecting accountability' for executive overreach. 'California’s governor is rewriting history to justify policies that ignore constitutional principles,' said Cruz spokesperson Kyle Ellingsworth in an email to reporters.
Conservative analysts echoed the criticism. Fox News contributor Jennifer Gratz argued on air that Newsom’s rebuttal 'exposes the left’s refusal to engage with factual history,' adding, 'Cruz called out the emperor’s new clothes.'
What the Numbers Show
A Jan. 2026 Quinnipiac University poll found Newsom with 48% approval among California residents, while Cruz’s approval in Texas stands at 52%, according to a University of Texas/Texas Tribune survey. Both figures reflect stable ratings over the past six months.
Newsom has issued 17 executive orders since January 2025, with six directly related to energy and education policy—the focus of Cruz’s remarks. Cruz’s Senate votes against Newsom’s policy priorities align with 89% of his GOP colleagues, per Senate voting records.
The Bottom Line
The exchange highlights deepening partisan divides over federal-state dynamics and historical interpretation in policymaking. Both sides have indicated no immediate resolution, with Newsom’s team planning a statewide tour to defend his executive agenda and Cruz vowing to 'hold the line' on what he calls 'misguided governance.'
Watch for further interactions during the March 2026 California policy summit and potential legislative pushes in Texas targeting similar issues.