Chicago is projected to spend $3.9 billion on debt service in its 2027 spending plan, a sum that will not fund any direct city services such as pothole repairs, trash collection, or emergency response. This figure represents the largest debt burden among major U.S. cities, according to an analysis by WTTW News and ProPublica. The city’s total outstanding debt stands at $55 billion, largely driven by underfunded pension obligations and a history of borrowing that has weakened its credit standing.
What the Right Is Saying
Fiscal conservatives and business leaders point to Chicago’s credit rating, which sits just two or three levels above junk status, as evidence of poor financial management. According to the major Wall Street credit-rating agencies, New York’s and Los Angeles’ fiscal health makes them significantly more attractive to investors. Chicago’s history of questionable borrowing and its failure to meet pension payments in previous years have undermined its credibility in the financial markets.
Critics argue that the city’s reliance on borrowing to fund ongoing operations is unsustainable. The resignation of the city’s chief financial officer last week, who cited concerns for her "integrity and professional obligations," is viewed by some as a signal of deep-seated management issues. The CFO, who had been on the job for only three months and came from Fitch Ratings, left the role in what was described as a stunning fashion.
Opponents of Mayor Johnson’s proposed corporate taxes argue that such measures face stiff resistance and may further deter investment in the city. They contend that the administration’s focus on new taxes does not address the root cause of the debt: excessive spending and inadequate reserve funds. Business groups have warned that increasing the tax burden on corporations could lead to job losses and reduced economic activity.
Some conservative commentators highlight the disparity between Chicago’s debt levels and those of other major cities. New York City, with a population three times the size of Chicago’s and a budget more than seven times as big, has $47 billion in debt backed by tax revenues. Los Angeles, with approximately 1 million more residents than Chicago but a smaller budget, has only $1 billion in debt set to be paid back with taxes. These comparisons are used to argue that Chicago’s fiscal policies are outliers among major metropolitan areas.
Critics also note that the city has negotiated agreements with lenders to pay only interest for several years, effectively backloading its debt burden. This strategy, they argue, delays the inevitable cost of repayment and shifts the financial burden to future taxpayers. The reliance on such financial engineering is seen as a sign of short-term thinking rather than long-term fiscal planning.
The pension crisis is cited as a primary driver of the city’s financial instability. With most pension funds less than 50% funded, Chicago is an outlier among large cities, where most pensions are at least 75% funded. Fiscal conservatives argue that the city must address these unfunded liabilities through structural reforms, including potential changes to benefit structures or retirement ages, rather than relying solely on additional contributions or borrowing.
What the Left Is Saying
Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration attributes the current financial constraints to "reckless financing methods" employed by previous administrations. In a statement to WTTW and ProPublica, the city’s Office of Budget and Management noted that "savings and efficiencies alone cannot solve the city’s persistent structural gap," emphasizing that past mismanagement has created a binding fiscal reality that limits current options.
Progressive voices within the city argue that the burden of debt service disproportionately affects underserved communities on the South and West sides. Mayor Johnson’s spokesperson stated that recent borrowing has "advanced desperately needed investment in economic development and affordable housing in historically underserved communities," framing the debt as a tool for necessary social and economic infrastructure improvements that were previously neglected.
Advocates for public sector workers point to the city’s reliance on borrowing to meet contractual obligations as evidence of systemic underfunding. In 2026, Chicago borrowed $166 million to pay firefighters for work performed without a contract over four years, including annual raises. Officials acknowledged that the city failed to set aside sufficient cash annually to cover these anticipated costs, leading to immediate financial strain on the municipal budget.
Labor unions and progressive organizations have resisted proposals to cut city jobs, particularly within the police department, which remains the city’s largest workforce. They argue that reducing staffing levels would degrade public safety and essential services, undermining the quality of life for residents who already face significant economic challenges. The administration has sought to balance these demands by pursuing new revenue streams, including taxes on large corporations.
The city’s approach to pension funding has been highlighted by supporters as a stabilizing force. Since 2023, Chicago has paid an additional $1 billion into its four pension funds above the amounts required by state law. Proponents of this strategy argue that these voluntary contributions demonstrate a commitment to fiscal responsibility and long-term stability, even as they divert funds from other immediate needs.
Critics of the status quo note that the lack of public and political appetite for raising property taxes or cutting jobs leaves limited options for a financial rescue. They argue that without significant structural changes or new revenue sources, the city will continue to borrow to cover operational shortfalls, exacerbating the debt burden for future generations.
What the Numbers Show
Chicago’s total outstanding debt is $55 billion, the highest among major U.S. cities according to WTTW News and ProPublica. In the 2026 budget, $3.6 billion out of a $16.6 billion total budget was consumed by debt service. For the upcoming 2027 spending plan, $3.9 billion is projected to go toward debt service, representing a significant portion of the city’s revenue.
The city’s credit rating is just two or three levels above junk status, making the cost of borrowing more expensive. This rating reflects concerns from major Wall Street credit-rating agencies about Chicago’s fiscal health compared to peer cities. New York City has $47 billion in debt backed by tax revenues, while Los Angeles has $1 billion in debt set to be paid back with taxes, despite having a larger population than Chicago.
Chicago’s pension systems are less than 50% funded, compared to most large cities where pensions are at least 75% funded. Since taking office in 2023, Mayor Johnson has added $1.9 billion to the city’s debt obligations. However, the city has also paid an additional $1 billion into its four pension funds above what is required by state law since 2023.
In 2026, Chicago borrowed $166 million to cover unpaid wages and raises for firefighters and $267 million to cover the cost of lawsuits alleging police misconduct. These borrowings were necessary to cover operational costs that had not been adequately reserved in previous budgets. The city’s aviation budget, which funds O’Hare and Midway airports, is a separate category, but debt service remains the largest category of the city’s budget in 2026.
The resignation of the city’s chief financial officer last week highlights the severity of the situation. The CFO, who had been on the job for only three months, stated that continuing in the role would compromise her "integrity and professional obligations." This departure marks a significant disruption in the city’s financial management team.
Data from 2025 city budgets and pension reports, as of September 2026, show that most cities have multiple pension funds with varying levels of funding. Chicago’s range between its least and most funded pension funds indicates a significant structural deficit. The city’s options for financial rescue are limited, with little public or political appetite for raising property taxes or cutting city jobs.
The Bottom Line
Chicago’s $55 billion debt burden poses a significant threat to the sustainability of city services, with billions of dollars annually diverted to debt service rather than direct public works and emergency response. The city’s credit rating, just above junk status, increases the cost of borrowing and limits its financial flexibility. The resignation of the chief financial officer underscores the severity of the fiscal challenges facing the administration.
The city’s reliance on borrowing to cover operational shortfalls, including unpaid wages and legal settlements, indicates a structural gap that current measures have not resolved. While Mayor Johnson’s administration has increased pension contributions and invested in underserved communities, these actions have also added $1.9 billion to the debt since 2023. The political resistance to tax increases and job cuts limits the options for immediate fiscal relief.
Comparisons with New York and Los Angeles highlight Chicago’s unique fiscal position among major U.S. cities. Despite having a smaller population and budget than New York, Chicago carries a higher debt burden relative to its revenue. The city’s pension systems, less than 50% funded, remain a primary driver of its financial instability. Future budgets will likely continue to prioritize debt service, potentially impacting the quality and availability of public services for residents.