Chicago’s chief financial officer, Ashlee Gabrysch, resigned on Friday after only three months in the role, citing concerns about the city’s financial integrity. The departure of the former Fitch Ratings executive has intensified scrutiny of Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration as it navigates a contentious fight over the fiscal year 2027 budget.
In her resignation letter, obtained by the Chicago Tribune, Gabrysch stated she could no longer fulfill her professional obligations under the current conditions of her employment. She emphasized that the CFO’s statements are relied upon by investors, rating agencies, the City Council, and taxpayers, and must be complete and accurate. Mayor Johnson’s office did not immediately respond to requests for comment, but his press secretary characterized Gabrysch as largely absent during key parts of the budget creation process.
What the Left Is Saying
Supporters of Mayor Johnson and the city administration argue that Gabrysch’s departure does not reflect a fundamental flaw in the budget’s structure. City Comptroller Michael Belsky maintained that proposed revenues matched expenditures, while acting Budget Director Jonathan Ernst defended the administration’s calculations. The administration asserts that 76% of its budget measures address underlying financial problems, a figure they believe demonstrates a commitment to fiscal responsibility.
Johnson, who announced a projected $882 million shortfall for 2027 in September, stated that the city faces difficult but necessary decisions to address structural challenges that have persisted for decades. The administration adjusted the deficit figure to $662 million by accounting for planned borrowing to fund police settlement amounts, arguing this is a standard accounting practice to manage immediate liabilities.
What the Right Is Saying
Critics of the administration, including some Democratic aldermen, view the resignation as a red flag regarding Johnson’s fiscal management. Ald. Marty Quinn, D-Midway, stated he was not surprised by the mayor’s handling of the budget, describing the administration’s approach as potentially disingenuous. Quinn and other skeptics argue that the administration’s adjustment of the deficit figure obscures the true extent of the city’s financial obligations.
The mayor’s office has shifted some of the focus to Gabrysch herself, accusing her of improperly directing a $75 million payment to city pension funds before required legal procedures were completed. The administration announced it would refer this matter to the Chicago Office of Inspector General for review, suggesting that the CFO’s own actions warrant scrutiny.
What the Numbers Show
The core of the dispute centers on deficit calculations and the composition of the budget. Johnson announced a projected $882 million shortfall for 2027, which local media noted was smaller than the $1.15 billion deficit projected in 2025. However, Gabrysch challenged the administration’s adjusted figure of $662 million, arguing that settlement expenses should remain part of the deficit and that borrowing to pay them was a temporary fix rather than a lasting solution.
According to the Tribune, while the administration claimed 76% of budget measures addressed structural issues, Gabrysch calculated that figure at just 56%. Crain's Chicago Business reported that Gabrysch warned the city anticipated issuing $350 million in settlement-related bonds in 2027, with an estimated $190 million in interest costs over seven years. This comes amid a broader trend of turnover in Johnson's financial leadership, including two previous CFO departures this year and the resignation of the city's budget director in August.
The Bottom Line
The resignation has prompted Council Finance Committee Chairman Pat Dowell, D-South Loop, to call for an independent audit of the city’s finances. This development adds pressure on Mayor Johnson as he seeks to pass a $17.6 billion budget that Gabrysch had previously declined to call balanced during an October City Council hearing. The administration and the City Council must now navigate the remainder of the budget process amid heightened concerns about fiscal transparency and creditworthiness.