Former Commerce Department officials are describing the tenure of Secretary Howard Lutnick as marked by internal chaos and a failure to enforce national security bans on advanced computer chip exports to China. According to four former staff members who spoke to CBS News on condition of anonymity, the department experienced significant leadership turnover, micromanagement, and a refusal to utilize available enforcement tools. These allegations surface amid heightened scrutiny following the resignation of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and reports of substantial chip smuggling to Chinese entities.
The Commerce Department is responsible for investigating and enforcing export controls on advanced semiconductors used in artificial intelligence and weapons systems. Under previous administrations, the department maintained strict controls, including the Entity List, which restricts sales to firms suspected of routing technology to adversaries. However, former employees state that enforcement stalled under Lutnick, with no entities added to the list for a full year, a break in protocol not seen since 2008.
What the Left Is Saying
Progressive critics and former career officials argue that the Trump administration’s rollback of export controls in May 2025, which replaced strict regulations with industry guidance, has compromised U.S. national security. One former Commerce official stated, "There was an inexplicable refusal to use the tools at their disposal for national security over the last year." Former employees described a "complete stop" in adding firms to the Entity List, despite enforcement officers identifying suspicious activity at Southeast Asian sites where Nvidia chips were delivered.
Critics within the department have pointed to the departure of veteran officials Matthew Borman and Eileen Albanese, who left shortly after Lutnick took office. "They kicked off the administration by essentially firing the two most respected people," said one former employee. An ex-staff member noted that the resulting "exodus" of up to 50 skilled workers removed decades of institutional memory regarding AI, Russia, and diversion enforcement.
What the Right Is Saying
Conservative officials and the Trump administration have framed their approach to chip exports as a necessary correction to stifling regulations. The Commerce Department argued in May 2025 that previous rules "would have stifled American innovation," opting instead to strengthen controls through guidance. While the department did not respond to requests for comment on the specific allegations of chaos, the administration has maintained that its policy shifts were designed to balance national security with economic competitiveness.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, a key figure in the Trump economic team, expressed frustration with the enforcement outcomes but placed the onus on the Commerce Department's internal processes. "Commerce has the pen. You would have to ask them about their internal processes," Bessent told CNBC. He added, "I am frustrated when President Trump made it very clear that China should not receive any Nvidia chips above" a certain sophistication level. This perspective suggests that while the political directive was clear, the bureaucratic execution failed, rather than the policy itself being flawed.
What the Numbers Show
According to the Federal Register, the last time entities were added to the Commerce Department’s Entity List was Oct. 9, 2025. The previous yearlong gap in additions occurred in 2008, making the recent halt in enforcement actions statistically unusual. A study by AI research nonprofit Epoch estimated that between 290,000 and 1.6 million cutting-edge AI chips were smuggled into China in 2024 and 2025. This volume represents roughly a quarter of the computing power China acquired through legal channels or domestic production during that period.
Further data highlights the scale of potential leakage. Tech news site The Information reported that at least $7.5 billion worth of Nvidia chips allegedly ended up with Chinese companies since 2023 through entities linked to Alice Huang, a woman identified by U.S. intelligence as a suspected Chinese agent. Additionally, a former OpenAI researcher published a paper claiming digital forensic evidence that top Chinese AI models were trained using Nvidia chips that were officially banned from export to China.
The Bottom Line
The allegations of internal dysfunction and enforcement failures under Secretary Lutnick have prompted immediate policy adjustments. On Monday, the Commerce Department imposed a new rule requiring licenses for exporting, re-exporting, or transferring advanced semiconductors to Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, or Thailand. This measure aims to close loopholes used to route chips to China via intermediary countries. Key leadership roles within the Bureau of Industry and Security, including the principal deputy assistant secretary for export administration, remain vacant, according to federal employee registries. The situation remains developing as Congress and the administration assess whether the recent regulatory shifts will effectively curb chip diversion.