A new study by Infinity Advisory Services suggests the Internal Revenue Service may be systematically reducing the appraised value of conservation easements by an average of roughly 97% in tax dispute cases, raising concerns among landowners and critics that the agency is applying a predetermined formula rather than evaluating individual property facts. The report, which examined more than 130 IRS valuation reviews, found that in 115 cases with comparable figures, the agency slashed taxpayers’ appraised values, with reductions of 99% or more being common. This pattern has drawn attention from a former IRS valuator who described the agency's approach as having "lost its way."
Conservation easements allow landowners to claim charitable tax deductions for permanently giving up certain development rights on their property, which helps preserve farmland and forests while allowing the owner to retain title. The value of these donated rights is determined by an appraisal, which forms the basis of the tax deduction. The study argues that the consistent, drastic reductions across different properties, tax years, and reviewers indicate a process designed to reach a specific outcome, effectively wiping out the value underpinning the deductions.
What the Left Is Saying
While the study is framed by conservative voices, the underlying issue touches on federal tax enforcement policy. Proponents of strict IRS oversight often argue that conservation easement deductions have been subject to abuse, with some taxpayers inflating property values to claim excessive credits. The source material notes that fraud does exist in this sector, with Steve Moore stating that there are cases of fraud where people will way overvalue through a fraudulent appraisal. From a regulatory perspective, the government’s role is to ensure that tax incentives are not exploited by wealthy landowners to shelter income, a view that supports rigorous valuation standards even if they result in lower deductions.
The whistleblower cited in the report, however, emphasized that the current approach is not solely about catching fraud but reflects a broader cultural shift within the agency. "Some of it is due to the fact that the IRS is in the business of trying to get as much money out of people as they can. And part of it is that there has been fraud," noted Steve Moore, chairman of Unleash Prosperity and a former advisor to President Donald Trump, who has highlighted the plight of honest taxpayers. Moore argued that the crackdown has swept up individuals who relied on qualified appraisers and professional advice, suggesting that enforcement has outpaced the need to distinguish between abusive shelters and legitimate conservation efforts.
What the Right Is Saying
Conservative commentators and the whistleblower characterize the IRS’s actions as an unfair burden on rural landowners and a deviation from neutral tax administration. The former IRS valuator, who spent many years at the agency, stated that officials pressured appraisers to reach predetermined conclusions and dismissed evidence from taxpayers. "I'm looking at the IRS, and they've developed a culture that says bigger dollars is a good thing," the whistleblower said. He argued that the agency is "setting up taxpayers that they know are innocent," leaving them facing steep tax bills and penalties rather than fairly evaluating each property.
The whistleblower further criticized the lack of expertise in the valuation process. "If you're going to have a valuation issue, it should be addressed by someone who has expertise in valuation. When I was at the IRS, that would not have been tolerated," he stated. He described a specific instance where an IRS Appeals technical advisor refused to hear a taxpayer’s explanations for eight areas of concern, saying, "I don't want to hear it." The whistleblower noted that the concerns should be viewed from a "factual perspective in a nonpartisan way," but highlighted that the application of the law appears "slanted" against taxpayers.
What the Numbers Show
The study conducted by Infinity Advisory Services examined over 130 IRS valuation reviews. In 115 conservation easement tax incentive cases where comparable figures were available, the IRS reduced taxpayers’ appraised values by an average of roughly 97%. The report noted that reductions of 99% or more were common across these cases. The authors concluded that the pattern is "consistent with" the view that the government's valuation position was "settled as a matter of policy before it was tested against the facts of individual properties."
One specific case cited in the study involved a historic building in Cleveland. According to the report, the same IRS reviewer initially valued a donated preservation easement between $18.1 million and $23.2 million. In a follow-up review, the value was reduced to $400,000, a change that dramatically shifted the landowner’s tax burden. The revised report explicitly cited instructions from IRS counsel to exclude certain development rights from consideration. The study’s authors argued that this reversal reflected a directive covering an entire class of properties rather than new evidence about the building itself.
The Bottom Line
The findings from Infinity Advisory Services and the whistleblower testimony highlight a growing tension between federal tax enforcement and property rights advocates. The study asserts that the data pattern is difficult to explain on any basis other than a predetermined policy outcome, suggesting that the IRS valuation process for conservation easements may be systematically discrediting taxpayer appraisals. Critics argue this creates an environment where honest landowners are penalized alongside those committing fraud, potentially discouraging conservation efforts.
The whistleblower stressed that this issue is not necessarily tied to a single administration but represents a cultural shift within the IRS regarding revenue collection and the treatment of taxpayer evidence. As the debate continues, the key question remains whether the agency’s valuation methods are appropriately rigorous in preventing abuse or overly aggressive in reducing legitimate deductions. Future developments may involve legislative scrutiny of IRS valuation guidelines or legal challenges from landowners who argue their deductions were unfairly reduced without proper consideration of individual property facts.