Chicago’s City Council voted 45-5 in a special meeting to grant Alderperson Pat Dowell, chair of the Finance Committee, the authority to hire an outside firm to independently review the city’s finances. The vote comes amid heightened scrutiny of the municipal budget following the abrupt resignation of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch and a recent warning from S&P Global that the city faces a potential credit downgrade within 90 days.
The ordinance empowers Dowell to spend necessary funds to determine if material or intentional misstatements of Chicago’s financial condition have occurred in public documents, presentations, or financial reporting over the prior three years. The hired firm will have access to all city records, and all officials are required to cooperate with the probe. This legislative action follows a series of reports by WTTW News and ProPublica highlighting a $55 billion debt burden and increased borrowing to cover operational shortfalls, including large police settlements.
What the Right Is Saying
Former Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch, whose resignation triggered the debate, argued that the political environment forced her to downplay facts about the city’s financial situation. In a commentary for the Chicago Tribune, Gabrysch stated, "Don’t borrow to pay everyday bills, even if we’ve done so in the past," outlining her view that the administration’s approach to debt management lacked integrity. She reiterated her support for a financial audit in an interview with the Chicago Sun-Times.
Mayor Brandon Johnson stated that he welcomes the independent review and will not veto the ordinance. However, the administration has faced criticism for its reliance on borrowing to address budget gaps. Justin Marlowe, director of the Center for Municipal Finance at the University of Chicago, noted that while an audit might not be necessary for every discrepancy, the ongoing public disagreement over basic financial facts creates uncertainty that investors dislike. "The way cities make their budgets matter," Marlowe said. "It matters that for the third year in a row that there are disagreements over basic facts."
What the Left Is Saying
Alderperson Pat Dowell, who initially endorsed Mayor Brandon Johnson in 2023 and was appointed to lead the Finance Committee, stated that the review is essential to ensure fiscal accuracy. "We must ensure that our math is correct," Dowell said. "The discrepancies over the past few weeks have been particularly disturbing to me. As my mother used to say, where there’s smoke, there’s fire."
Dowell has emerged as a critic of Mayor Johnson’s recent financial proposals, including his push for a $25 per month per employee tax on firms with more than 125 employees. Alderperson Matt Martin, another council member, described the reporting on the city's debt as "sobering" and indicated he is questioning specific borrowing strategies employed by the Johnson administration. The council's move reflects a shift from traditional acquiescence to mayoral financial directives, driven by concerns over the sustainability of the city's current fiscal path.
What the Numbers Show
The City Council vote was 45-5 in favor of the ordinance. S&P Global placed the city on credit watch with a warning that the current budget negotiations could result in a credit downgrade within 90 days. Reports indicate Chicago carries a $55 billion debt burden. The state-mandated deadline for passing the 2027 budget is Dec. 29, and it remains unclear if the independent review will be completed in time for the council to consider its findings before that date. Dowell’s ordinance covers financial reporting for the prior three years.
The Bottom Line
The independent review introduces a significant variable into Chicago’s budget process, with the potential to alter the narrative around the city’s fiscal health just as credit rating agencies assess the risk of a downgrade. Mayor Johnson and Council Chair Dowell, once allies, are now navigating a contentious relationship over fiscal policy, with the council asserting its authority to investigate the administration’s financial representations. The outcome of the review and the subsequent budget negotiations will likely determine Chicago’s credit standing and its ability to service its growing debt load in the coming years.