Former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola has won Alaska's U.S. Senate contest, defeating Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan, according to a race call by The Associated Press. Peltola's victory marks the first time a Democrat has won a Senate race in Alaska since 2008 and makes her the first Alaska Native to serve in the U.S. Senate. With this win, Democrats will hold 56 seats in the upcoming Congress.
Although Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, Peltola secured a majority of first-place votes, meaning no ranked-choice calculation was necessary. The outcome is notable because President Donald Trump carried Alaska by 13 percentage points in the 2024 presidential election. The race concluded amidst legal challenges and allegations regarding a third candidate, Dan J. Sullivan, whose presence on the ballot sparked disputes over voter confusion.
What the Left Is Saying
Peltola's campaign focused on affordability, healthcare costs, and allegations of corruption within the Republican party. The campaign emphasized issues specific to rural Alaska, where the cost of groceries and gas can be double or triple the national average. Peltola, who is from Bethel, a hub city not connected to the state's road system, centered her platform on the salmon crisis on the Yukon and Kuskokwim rivers, a topic that previously propelled her to statewide prominence in 2022.
Peltola positioned herself as the candidate who would crack down on industrial-scale pollock fishing in the Bering Sea, which Alaskans increasingly blame for wasting salmon and halibut. Her campaign motto, "fish, family, freedom," reflected these priorities. Regarding the controversy over the second Dan Sullivan, Peltola's campaign denied involvement in efforts to recruit another candidate to the race to siphon votes from the incumbent.
What the Right Is Saying
Incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan, a Marine Corps veteran and former Alaska attorney general, campaigned as a strong advocate for increasing military and Coast Guard presence in the state. Sullivan maintained his status as a steadfast ally of President Trump, who held a rally in Wasilla last month to boost Sullivan's candidacy. However, the election results suggest that declining approval ratings for the president, driven by opposition to the Iran war and high prices, negatively impacted Republican incumbents in the state.
Republicans, including the Trump administration and Sen. Sullivan, claimed that the candidacy of Dan J. Sullivan was designed to trick voters. The U.S. Justice Department stated that "Alaskan voters deserve a fair election, not to be misled in an attempt to rig outcomes." The department filed a lawsuit seeking to block the certification of the results, arguing that the presence of two candidates named Dan Sullivan on the ranked-choice ballot could have confused voters.
What the Numbers Show
Peltola won a majority of first-place votes, avoiding the need for ranked-choice tabulation. Preliminary results indicate that Peltola received more votes than the other three candidates combined as of Sunday. The Associated Press called the race in Peltola's favor. President Trump had won Alaska by 13 percentage points in the 2024 presidential election, highlighting the shift in voter sentiment in this Senate contest.
Super PACs aligned with both major parties spent more than $2 million on "ballot composition" efforts in Alaska this year. These efforts sometimes elevated candidates who do not live in the state, including a federal inmate in New York. Ballot stacking and promoting spoilers are generally legal in Alaska and have been relatively common in recent elections.
The Bottom Line
A federal judge rejected the Trump administration's lawsuit to block the certification of the results, ruling that such an order would "clearly violate" Alaskan voters' right to a secret ballot. The U.S. Justice Department plans to appeal this dismissal. Additionally, Alaska's governor has ordered an investigation into the race. With Peltola's victory, Democrats will have 56 Senators in the next Congress, a significant gain in a state that has voted Republican in the last three presidential cycles.