Former President Joe Biden’s memoir, "Promise Me, America," released Nov. 17, has drawn sharp criticism from reviewers who characterize the book as an exercise in "denial" regarding his 2024 re-election bid and his administration’s handling of the war in Gaza. The book defends Biden’s presidency and his decision to seek a second term, but critics argue it fails to adequately account for the factors that led to his withdrawal from the race.
Reviews from major outlets including The New Yorker, The New York Times, and Semafor highlight omissions regarding racial equity policies and what critics describe as passive language concerning Palestinian suffering. The debate centers on whether the memoir provides a candid assessment of Biden’s final year in office or primarily serves to "burnish" his legacy.
What the Left Is Saying
Progressive and liberal critics argue that the memoir lacks sufficient self-reflection on key policy decisions and personal accountability. Amy Davidson Sorkin of The New Yorker stated that Biden remains "stubbornly in denial," particularly regarding questions about his age and his continued insistence that he could have won the election.
Jennifer Szalai, a nonfiction critic for The New York Times, wrote that Biden "does not" own his losses, noting that he becomes "awkward and defensive" when addressing his handling of the war in Gaza and his decision to run for re-election. Szalai argued that Biden portrays himself as a "helpless victim of events" rather than an active participant in the political dynamics that unfolded.
On the issue of Gaza, critics including Sorkin, Szalai, and the socialist website Jacobin contended that Biden described his relationship with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as more adversarial than it was in practice. Szalai specifically noted a disparity in how victims were portrayed, writing that Biden used names to identify Israeli victims but offered "no names" for Palestinian victims, describing Palestinian suffering in passive terms.
What the Right Is Saying
Conservative and right-leaning commentators have focused on what they perceive as inconsistencies in Biden’s stated principles and a lack of doctrinal clarity in his foreign policy account. Israeli journalist and political commentator Amit Segal described Biden’s account of Israel policy as "devoid of doctrine or strategy," stating that "the only consistent position is inconsistency."
Critics also highlighted omissions related to Biden’s domestic policy legacy. Semafor politics reporter David Weigel noted that while Biden recounts signing 17 executive orders on his first day in office, the memoir does not mention the order establishing a government-wide approach to racial equity, which mandated every executive agency to develop a DEI action plan.
Weigel observed that the word "equity" does not appear in the memoir once. He pointed out that Biden argues "every one of my legislative accomplishments had justice baked in," citing "equal access to vaccines," but fails to reference the specific equity mandates of his early presidency.
What the Numbers Show
According to reviews by The New York Times and Semafor, the memoir contains specific omissions regarding key executive actions. David Weigel reported that the word "equity" appears zero times in the text, despite Biden signing an executive order on his first day that established a government-wide approach to racial equity.
Weigel also noted that the word "transgender" does not appear in the memoir, even though Biden had previously called anti-transgender discrimination "the civil rights issue of our time." The book does not mention the Day 1 executive order that banned discrimination on the basis of gender identity.
In its review, the Associated Press reported that Biden states in the book that he believed he was the best person to defeat President Donald Trump and that the Democratic primaries gave him no warning that he was in trouble. This account contrasts with the widespread polling and reporting during the 2024 cycle that indicated significant voter concern over his age and debate performance.
The Bottom Line
The publication of "Promise Me, America" has intensified the ongoing debate about how Biden’s presidency will be remembered, particularly regarding his withdrawal from the 2024 race and his foreign policy decisions. The criticism from both left and right suggests a shared view that the memoir prioritizes legacy defense over candid accountability.
Key areas to watch include how future historians and political analysts weigh the memoir’s accounts against contemporaneous records, particularly regarding the Gaza conflict and domestic equity policies. The lack of reference to specific executive orders on equity and gender identity in the book may influence discussions about the durability of those policies under the current administration.
As the political landscape shifts under President Donald Trump, the framing of Biden’s final year in office remains a contested point in Democratic Party discourse. The memoir’s reception indicates that internal party debates about leadership, policy priorities, and electoral strategy will continue to shape the narrative around the Biden era.