Former national security officials offered sharply divergent assessments of the trilateral summit between President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin in China. While one expert characterized the meeting as a successful step toward peace and nuclear disarmament, another argued that significant human rights and security issues were overlooked in favor of symbolic diplomacy. The debate highlights the ongoing tension between transactional engagement and values-based foreign policy in U.S.-China-Russia relations.
What the Left Is Saying
Dennis Wilder, former senior director for East Asia under President George W. Bush, expressed concern that the summit prioritized face-saving gestures for Xi and Putin over concrete U.S. strategic interests. Wilder stated that while he supports leader diplomacy, the administration failed to address critical issues such as Chinese arms supplies to Russia, support for Iran, and the incarceration of dissidents like Jimmy Lai in Hong Kong. He noted that an American academic remains imprisoned in China on espionage charges, a topic he said was not raised. Wilder argued that the U.S. is moving at a "snail's pace" on key negotiations and that giving Xi and Putin diplomatic legitimacy without securing concessions is a strategic error.
Wilder also addressed the nuclear arms discussion, agreeing that the topic is important but noting that Chinese experts have consistently refused to enter negotiations until they achieve parity with U.S. and Russian arsenals, a milestone projected for 2030 or 2035. He described previous attempts to engage the Chinese military on this issue as hostile, recounting an instance where a Chinese Rocket Force general shouted at him during a Pentagon meeting. On Ukraine, Wilder questioned what the U.S. received in return for the goodwill shown to Putin, pointing to Putin's recent demands that Finland leave NATO and that frontline states be disarmed.
What the Right Is Saying
Fred Fleitz, former National Security Council chief of staff under President Trump, defended the summit as a significant diplomatic achievement. Fleitz stated that President Trump accomplished his primary objective of reasserting his presence on the world stage and signaling a robust foreign policy agenda. He argued that the approach differs fundamentally from the previous administration's strategy, noting that demonizing Putin as a "war criminal" and "killer" precludes dialogue. Fleitz contended that Trump is setting the stage for major agreements, including efforts to end the war in Ukraine, by maintaining open channels of communication.
Fleitz emphasized that effective diplomacy requires raising sensitive issues in private rather than publicly embarrassing partners. He highlighted progress on nuclear disarmament as a key win, noting that while China possesses 400 to 600 nuclear warheads compared to the over 5,000 held by the U.S. and Russia, any reduction is critical. Fleitz argued that China must engage in disarmament talks and allow inspections to be viewed as a global peacemaker. Regarding Ukraine, he stated that Trump's team is convincing Putin that he cannot win the war and that a Democratic president in 2029 might take radical steps, such as admitting Ukraine into NATO, which would destabilize the region further.
What the Numbers Show
The summit centered on three major areas: nuclear disarmament, the war in Ukraine, and international legal institutions. Regarding nuclear capabilities, Fleitz cited data indicating China holds approximately 400 to 600 nuclear warheads, a fraction of the more than 5,000 warheads held by both the United States and Russia. Experts referenced by Wilder suggest China will not enter arms control negotiations until it reaches parity with these established powers, a goal not expected until 2030 or 2035. On the international legal front, the Trump administration joined a statement criticizing the International Criminal Court (ICC). Fleitz described the ICC as an "illegitimate court" that lacks due process protections for American citizens, noting the U.S. withdrew from the treaty in 2002. Wilder agreed with this assessment, stating he agreed "completely" with Fleitz on the ICC issue.
The Bottom Line
The divergent views from Wilder and Fleitz underscore a fundamental disagreement on the utility of high-level summits with autocratic leaders. The Right argues that maintaining dialogue and avoiding public confrontation is essential for achieving long-term goals like nuclear disarmament and ending the Ukraine war. The Left contends that this approach sacrifices leverage on human rights and regional security issues without yielding immediate concessions. As the administration continues to push for nuclear talks and a resolution in Ukraine, the effectiveness of this diplomatic strategy will likely remain a subject of intense debate among policy experts. The consensus on the ICC criticism suggests a rare area of alignment between the two perspectives, reflecting a broader bipartisan skepticism of international judicial bodies that claim jurisdiction over U.S. citizens.