The Trump administration on Thursday asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to dismiss a civil lawsuit it filed in October regarding the Alaska Senate race. The Justice Department sought to declare the case moot after Democratic candidate Mary Peltola won the election, effectively conceding the legal challenge to block certification of the state-run election.
The lawsuit, which sought the extraordinary step of preventing certification unless the Republican candidate emerged victorious, centered on President Donald Trump’s claims that the inclusion of candidate Dan J. Sullivan alongside Sen. Dan S. Sullivan was a stunt to defraud voters. The administration argued that the similar names would cause confusion at the ballot box.
What the Right Is Saying
In its filing, the Justice Department stated it brought the lawsuit to ensure that the State and its officers fulfill Alaska’s obligation to protect the integrity of its election. Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward acknowledged that there no longer exists any means of examining whether votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent. President Trump, who encouraged the lawsuit, told reporters during his midterm blitz in October, “I’m the one that said do it.”
What the Left Is Saying
Democrats and Alaska’s Republican-led state government characterized the lawsuit as meritless. The state government requested that a federal judge permanently dismiss the case, a plea that was granted on Nov. 1. The judge rejected the administration’s request to separate and preserve certain ballots, aligning with the view that the legal theory was unprovable and the intervention was a political maneuver rather than a legal necessity.
What the Numbers Show
Mary Peltola won Alaska’s Senate race with an outright majority, meaning the state did not have to use its ranked-choice voting tabulation process to determine a winner. Because the outcome was decided in the first round of counting, the distribution of votes between Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and Dan J. Sullivan did not affect the final result. The ability to prove voter confusion was widely considered an insurmountable legal hurdle from the start.
The Bottom Line
The dismissal request marks the end of a high-profile legal challenge by the Trump administration against a state election result. While the DOJ cited election integrity as its initial motivation, the mootness filing confirms that the administration’s legal strategy could not overcome the factual reality of Peltola’s majority win. The case highlights the limits of federal intervention in state election administration, particularly when the outcome is clear and independent of the alleged irregularity.