North Carolina Gov. Josh Stein stated that his state must roll back subsidies for data centers, arguing that technology companies should be "paying their own way." Speaking at the National Governors Association’s New Governors Leadership Forum in Deer Valley, Utah, the Democratic governor identified electricity subsidies and equipment purchase incentives as key areas for reduction.
"I think the idea that this industry needs any public incentive is laughable," Stein said. "These are the wealthiest companies in the history of humanity. They have more resources than many nations. So we, little North Carolina, should not be giving subsidies."
What the Right Is Saying
While the source material focuses primarily on Stein's remarks, the conservative perspective in North Carolina is represented by the Republican-led state Senate, which currently holds a narrow majority pending a recount in a pivotal race. The divided legislature reflects the ongoing political tension over economic development strategies.
Republicans have traditionally supported tax incentives and subsidies as tools to attract business investment and stimulate job growth in the state. The potential rollback of these subsidies, as proposed by Stein, may face opposition from legislators who view such incentives as essential for maintaining North Carolina's competitive edge in the tech sector.
Stein acknowledged the bipartisan nature of Hurricane Helene recovery efforts but noted the political divide in the legislature, which will likely influence the debate over data center subsidies in the coming year.
What the Left Is Saying
Governor Stein, representing the progressive perspective, framed the issue as one of economic equity and corporate responsibility. He argued that the immense wealth of Big Tech companies renders public incentives unnecessary and that the burden of infrastructure costs should fall on the corporations rather than the state.
"For new data centers, why are we giving them any public dollar when they should be subsidizing the ratepayers?" Stein asked. He pointed to previous rollbacks of electricity subsidies as a precedent for phasing out remaining incentives for new equipment purchases.
Stein also highlighted his administration's focus on recovery efforts following Hurricane Helene, noting that state resources are strained by $60 billion in damages. He criticized the federal government's lack of response, stating, "The state stepped up... and it's time for the federal government to step up."
What the Numbers Show
North Carolina Governor Josh Stein was elected in 2024, winning by nearly 15 points despite President Donald Trump also carrying the state that year. The state has recently seen a shift in legislative power, with Democrats flipping the North Carolina House of Representatives and breaking the Republican supermajority in the state Senate.
Hurricane Helene, which struck western North Carolina in 2024, caused approximately $60 billion in damages. This figure is nearly equivalent to the state’s entire two-year budget, limiting the state's ability to fund recovery efforts without federal assistance.
Stein did not commit to a 2028 reelection bid but stated he "cannot think of any" reasons not to run again.
The Bottom Line
The debate over data center subsidies highlights a growing tension between fiscal conservatism and economic development incentives in North Carolina. With a divided legislature and significant budget constraints due to hurricane recovery, the state faces difficult decisions on how to balance corporate incentives with taxpayer relief.
Key developments to watch include the outcome of the pending recount in the state Senate, which will determine the balance of power for the upcoming legislative session. Additionally, the federal response to North Carolina's request for Hurricane Helene recovery funds remains a critical issue for Stein's administration and state budget planning.
Stein's comments signal a potential shift in North Carolina's approach to tech industry incentives, emphasizing corporate responsibility over public subsidy as the state navigates its post-hurricane economic landscape.